Why does this for i,v in pair loop ignore if statements?

Remove = function(self,Tool)
        for i, v in ipairs(Spots) do
            print(v, Tool, i, Current)
            if v == Tool and tonumber(Current) == tonumber(i) then
                Spots[i] = true
                script.Parent:FindFirstChild(i).IMG.Image = ""
                break
            end
        end
        print("--------------------------------")
    end

Output

 ClassicSword ClassicSword 1 2
  ClassicSword ClassicSword 2 2 -- MATCH
  true ClassicSword 3 2
  true ClassicSword 4 2
  true ClassicSword 5 2
  --------------------------------

In this script, it gets the tools name, but to make the inventory more precise, it also checks the current tool you're holding. As you can see in the output, there was a match, both if statements were fulfilled. But it ignored that and went on. Why does it do this?

Also, spots is just a directory of free spots inside the inventory.

Spots = {
    [1] = true;
    [2] = true;
    [3] = true;
    [4] = true;
    [5] = true;
}