Should I use a RemoteEvent or a RemoteFunction for a GUI?
Hello all,
I have a question here. I've recently turned on FilteringEnabled in my place so I'm changing the scripts. I am confused if I should use a RemoteEvent or RemoteFunction. What I want to happen is that whenever the button in the gui is pressed the RemoteEvent/Function is passed on and that should give the player (which will be in a textbox) an item. But I do not know whether I should use a RemoteEvent or Function and how the code in the RemoteEvent/Function will work.
PS: I have already read all wiki threads about this and tried everything and it still does not work. I have also already tried changing to a RemoteFunction. In case you're wondering, nothing is showing up in the output.
Here's the code in the gui:
script.Parent.confirm.MouseButton1Click:connect(function(player)
game.ReplicatedStorage.GiveRoom:FireServer(player)
end)
Here's the code in the RemoteEvent:
script.Parent.OnServerEvent:connect(function(player)
local reception = player:WaitForChild('PlayerGui').Reception.FrameA.CheckIn
if reception.errormsg.Text == "Error: Room not available" then
warn("Room not available") else
if game.Players[reception.username.Text] then
game.ServerStorage.ReceptionSystem.RoomsFolder["Room"..reception.roomnum.Text].Value = true
local newVal = Instance.new("StringValue", game.ServerStorage.ReceptionSystem.CheckedIn)
newVal.Name = "Room"..reception.roomnum.Text
newVal.Value = game.Players[reception.username.Text].Name
local newKey = game.ServerStorage.ReceptionSystem.Card:Clone()
newKey.Parent = game.Players[reception.username.Text].Backpack
newKey.Name = "Room "..reception.roomnum.Text
newKey.CardNumber.Value = reception.roomnum.Text
local newKey2 = game.ServerStorage.ReceptionSystem.Card:Clone()
newKey2.Parent = game.Players[reception.username.Text].StarterGear
newKey2.Name = 'Room '..reception.roomnum.Text
newKey2.CardNumber.Value = reception.roomnum.Text
reception.confirm.Text = "Checked in!"
reception.roomnum.Text = "Enter room number"
reception.username.Text = "Enter username"
wait(0.5)
reception.confirm.Text = "Check-in"
end
end
reception.roomnum.Changed:connect(function()
reception.errormsg.Text = " "
if game.ServerStorage.ReceptionSystem.CheckedIn["Room"..reception.roomnum.Text] then
reception.errormsg.Text = "Error: Room not available"
end
end)
end)
Thanks in advance!
0
1 answer
I would use a RemoteEvent to do everything you're doing with the Keys and keep the GUI stuff to the LocalScript. If you need anything from the keys in the local script, use a RemoteFunction instead to return it. Remember, anything you do with a LocalScript with FE is only going to be visible to you.
You use a RemoteFunction when you want the script to yield (wait) until the function returns something. For instance, what if I made a Local script that needed something that only could be accessed by a Server script, like something in SeverStorage? I would need to yield until that object is returned to continue on with the script, else it'll return nil because it continued without waiting for the returned object.
In summary via Wiki "A RemoteFunction sends a request and then waits for a response, while RemoteEvents just send a request."
You can visualize this by structuring your scripts like so and trying each of these examples.
RemoteFunction example
--Inside the LocalScript
local RemoteFunction = script:WaitForChild('RemoteFunction')
local now = tick()
local returned = RemoteFunction:InvokeServer()
print(returned, tick() - now) -- prints what it returned and how long it yielded until something was returned.
-- Inside the script
local RemoteFunction = Instance.new("RemoteFunction", script.Parent)
function RemoteFunction.OnServerInvoke()
for i = 1, 5 do
wait(.5)
end
return 'bagel'
end
RemoteEvent example
--Inside the LocalScript
local RemoteEvent = script:WaitForChild('RemoteEvent')
local now = tick()
local returned = RemoteEvent:FireServer()
print(returned, tick() - now) -- prints nil and some huge value, because it didn't yield at all.
-- Inside the script
local RemoteEvent = Instance.new("RemoteEvent", script.Parent)
RemoteEvent.OnServerEvent:connect(function()
for i = 1, 5 do
wait(.5)
end
return 'bagel'
end)
0