I have my code grabbing the image but is there a way to make it come as a circle or would I have to make the image label itself round?
You can get the player his actual thumbnail using GetUserThumbnailAsync.
Those however are just regular square images. If you need them round you can add an ImageLabel as a child of your ImageLabel that contains the thumbnail. The child image would contain a round border so you can hide the corners of the image.