I'm having troubles with StarterGear not assigning Tools?

Hey, I'm actually working on a shopGUI which has the {Player} purchase a new Tool then afterwards it removes the current Tool in their Backpack and StarterGear then replaces it with the new Tool, however, whenever the {Player} resets, the old Tool comes back!

        local magicTools = shopItems[purchasedItem][purchasedItem]:Clone()
        magicTools.Parent = player.Backpack

        local oldMagicTool = player.Backpack:FindFirstChildOfClass("Tool")
        oldMagicTool:Destroy() 

        local magicTools = shopItems[purchasedItem][purchasedItem]:Clone()
        magicTools.Parent = player.StarterGear

        local oldMagicTool = player.StarterGear:FindFirstChildOfClass("Tool")
        oldMagicTool:Destroy()

The code above has "magicTools" assign the new tool purchased (which works just fine) then deletes the "oldMagicTool" (which also works just fine..) but as I said earlier, whenever the {Player} resets, the "oldMagicTool" comes back and the "magicTools" is gone.

I actually have the "tempFire" (which is the "oldMagicTool") inside of StarterPack and "tempLightning" inside of ServerStorage if any of this is helpful!

I'd appreciate any support I can get. :)