Rarity system not working quite well with this for loop?

I'm trying to make a script where it spawns items into a part who's parent is a folder with a rarity system, but keeps repeating the same strings. Is there another way to do this?

These are the items v

local Items = {
	{"Ikea Spell Book",1},
	{"Baguette Sword",1},
	{"Plant",10},
	{"Axe",10},
	{"Knife",10},
	{"Makeshift Spear",10},
	{"Angle Grinder",10},
}

Counts all the numbers in the table and adds it into TotalWeight

local TotalWeight = 0

for _,ItemData in pairs(Items) do
	TotalWeight = TotalWeight + ItemData[2]
end

Now we add it into the second function of math.random and then checks if the chance is lower or equal to Counter and if it is it returns the string

local function chooseRandomItem()
	local Chance = math.random(1,TotalWeight)
	local Counter = 0
	for _,ItemData in pairs(Items) do
		Counter = Counter + ItemData[2]
		if Chance <= Counter then
			return ItemData[1]
		end
	end
end

Now for the for loop that causes all of this

for _,v in pairs(script.Parent:GetChildren()) do
	if v:IsA("BasePart") then
		if not v:FindFirstChildOfClass("Model") then
			local RandomItem = chooseRandomItem()
			local clone = game.ServerStorage.Pickups:FindFirstChild(RandomItem):Clone()
			clone:SetPrimaryPartCFrame(v.CFrame)
			clone.Parent = v -- Clone, CFrame it to the part's position and then parent it to it.
		end
	end
end

Now my output: Plant, Axe (x13)

Why is this happening only with this for loop?

With this it works properly.

for i=1,10 do
	print(chooseRandomItem())
end

Now my output:

Knife, Makeshift Spear, Plant, Knife, Plant, Angle Grinder (x2), Makeshift Spear (x2), Axe

Is there anyway to fix this, or I am simply doing something wrong?

Sorry if you're getting confused with this post, I'm not very good with explaining things and this is my first post, so bare with me.

Here's the whole script to help you all though

local Items = {
	{"Ikea Spell Book",1},
	{"Baguette Sword",1},
	{"Plant",10},
	{"Axe",10},
	{"Knife",10},
	{"Makeshift Spear",10},
	{"Angle Grinder",10},
}

math.randomseed(tick())

local TotalWeight = 0

for _,ItemData in pairs(Items) do
	TotalWeight = TotalWeight + ItemData[2]
end

local function chooseRandomItem()
	local Chance = math.random(1,TotalWeight)
	local Counter = 0
	for _,ItemData in pairs(Items) do
		Counter = Counter + ItemData[2]
		if Chance <= Counter then
			return ItemData[1]
		end
	end
end

for _,v in pairs(script.Parent:GetChildren()) do
	if v:IsA("BasePart") then
		if not v:FindFirstChildOfClass("Model") then
			local RandomItem = chooseRandomItem()
			local clone = game.ServerStorage.Pickups:FindFirstChild(RandomItem):Clone()
			clone:SetPrimaryPartCFrame(v.CFrame)
			clone.Parent = v -- Clone, CFrame it to the part's position and then parent it to it.
		end
	end
end