Why won't it change the text on a textlabel?

local question = script.Parent.Parent
local fr2 = script.Parent.Parent.Parent.Parent.Frame2
script.Parent.MouseButton1Click:Connect(function()
    script.Parent.Parent.Parent.Visible = false
    wait(1) 
    local Response = math.random(5)
    wait(1)
    if Response == 1 then
    fr2.X.Text = "You asked "..question.Text.." and it replied with Yes."
	end

    if Response == 2 then
    fr2.X.Text = "You asked "..question.Text.." and it replied with No."
	end
    if Response == 3 then
    fr2.X.Text = "You asked "..question.Text.." and it replied with Maybe."   
	end
    if Response == 4 then
    fr2.X.Text = "You asked "..question.Text.." and it replied with Probably." 
	end
    if Response == 5 then
    fr2.X.Text = "You asked "..question.Text.." and it replied with Probably not."   
	end
    fr2.Visible = true
    wait(5)
    cd.MaxActivationDistance = 32
    fr2.Visible = false 
end)

You had every if condition within one another, so if response == 1 then if response == 2. That's how your's was.