Data Persistance/Store help?

I strongly suggest using DataStores for this

Since DataStores are limited to being unable to save Instances, you'll just need to save.. say a table full of strings with the weapon names and have those weapons in ServerStorage. So then when the player leaves you iterate through their backpack, save the table with all those names.. then when a player enters check if they have a key, if they do then load up the table and iterate through ServerStorage finding any matching names and cloning along the way(:

NOTE: DataStores are only Accessible through ServerScripts.

--Define the DataStore
local ds = game:GetService('DataStoreService'):GetDataStore('WeaponData')

--PlayerAdded event for when players enter
game.Players.PlayerAdded:connect(function(plr)
	--The Potential key in DataStores.. may return nil.
	local key = tostring(plr.userId).."_weapons"
	--Get the data, if nil then use an empty table
	local data = ds:GetAsync(key) or {}
	--Iterate through the table
	for i,v in pairs(data) do
		--If a weapon matches, clone it.
		local weapon = game.ServerStorage:FindFirstChild(tostring(v))
		if weapon then
			weapon:Clone().Parent = plr.Backpack
		end
	end
end)

--PlayerRemoving event for when players leave
game.Players.PlayerRemoving:connect(function(plr)
	--Define a table, and the key to save to
	local weps = {}
	local key = tostring(plr.userId).."_weapons"
	--Iterate through their backpack, insert strings into table
	for i,v in pairs(plr.Backpack:GetChildren()) do
		table.insert(weps,v.Name)
	end
	--If there's already data, we want to use UpdateAsync, otherwise use SetAsync
	local data = ds:GetAsync(key)
	if data then
		ds:UpdateAsync(key,function(old) return weps end)
	else
		ds:SetAsync(key,weps)
	end
end