How do I execute a script depending on a string value?

I've tried 2 attempts at this, I'm putting both of them here. But I know it's the top part that isn't working right but I can't find out why. When I put everything under "then" in a onclicked script it works perfect. I'm confused, anything helps.

while true do
RedBall = game.ReplicatedStorage.RedBall
if RedBall.Value == "true"
    then 
        newItem = game.ReplicatedStorage.Football.Handle:Clone() 
        newItem.Handle.CFrame = CFrame.new(-189.549, 1.8, -37.55) 
        newItem.Parent = workspace
            end
        end

2nd Attempt

while true do
    if game.ReplicatedStorage.RedBall.Value == "true"
    then
        print("gg")
        newItem = game.ReplicatedStorage.Football.Handle:Clone() 
        newItem.Handle.CFrame = CFrame.new(-189.549, 1.8, -37.55) 
        newItem.Parent = workspace
    end
end