Unable to cast value to objects?

This is the code i'm using to teleport players to a reserved server instance and it's not working. Whenever I attempt to teleport players (max player count of 1) I get Unable to cast value to object(s).

local TS = game:GetService("TeleportService")
local Players = game:GetService("Players")
local p = Players:GetPlayers()

if game.PrivateServerId ~= "" then
	game.ServerStorage.isVIP.Value = true
	reserve = TS:ReserveServer(IDREDACTED)
	wait(5)
	TS:TeleportToPrivateServer(IDREDACTED,reserve,{p})
end