Trying to find the player that touched a block. Help?

You have no way of knowing if the Player you're looking for exists, or what their name is, before connecting the Touched event; you have to get their Player from inside the function.

You also did your debounce a little wrong.

local enabled = true
script.Parent.Touched:connect(function(touchedEffect)
	if not enabled then return end
	--[[The Touched event gives one argument to the connected function: the Part that fired the event. Your variable, touchedEffect, is not well-named in that regard, so I thought I'd let you know how that works.]]
	if not touchedEffect then return end --bullets for instance tend to be Removed() or Destroyed() after hitting things.
	local character = touchedEffect.Parent --[[Declaring the variables as 'local' while inside a block of code (this function in this instance) limits their "scope" to that block. That is, 'character' and 'player' (on the next line) are undefined outside of this function.]]
	local player = Game.Players:GetPlayerFromCharacter(character)
	if not player then return end --[[touchedEffect will always have a parent, but GetPlayerFromCharacter returns nil for non-character models]]
    script.Parent.Transparency = 1
    script.Parent.CanCollide = false
    player.leaderstats.Pumpkins.Value = player.leaderstats.Pumpkins.Value +1
	enabled = false
    print'Pumpkin 1 has been collected. It will return in ten seconds!'
    wait(10)
    print'Pumpkin 1 has returned. It is now collectable!'
    script.Parent.Transparency = 0
    script.Parent.CanCollide = true
	enabled = true
end)