Why is remove async not removing data from my ordered data store?

I am trying to remove a player's user ID from a datastore, but remove async is not working. I used the right kind of parameters and everything, and it's not removing the data. Also, I'm using an ordered data store. When I tried printing it, it returned nil as well.

Script:

local function accumulate()
	local list = {}
	local nilCount = 0
	local key = 1
	while true do
		local value
		local success, notSuccess = pcall(function()
			value = dataStoreService:GetAsync(key)
		end)
		
		if success then
			print("Value obtained")
		else
			warn(notSuccess)
		end
		
		if value == nil then 
			nilCount = nilCount + 1 
		else
			table.insert(list, value)
		end
		
		if nilCount >= 2 then break end
		key = key + 1
	end
	
	return list
end

local function reorderData()
	local data = accumulate()
	local key = 1
	for _, value in pairs(data) do
		local success, notSuccess = pcall(function()
			dataStoreService:SetAsync(key, value)
		end)
		
		if success then
			print("Data ordered")
		else
			warn(notSuccess)
		end
		key = key + 1
	end
	
	print("Data Reordered")
end

local function removePlayer(player, plr)
	local key = 1
	local ID
	
	while true do
		local success, notSuccess = pcall(function()
			ID = dataStoreService:GetAsync(key)
		end)
		
		if success then
			print("Got player")
		else
			warn(notSuccess)
		end
		
		if plr.UserId == ID then
			print("Found")
			local success, notSuccess = pcall(function()
				local remove = dataStoreService:RemoveAsync(tostring(key))
				print(remove)
			end)
			
			if success then
				print("Unbanned Player")
			else
				warn(notSuccess)
			end
			
			break
		end
		key = key + 1
	end
	
	reorderData()
	
	return 0
end